Is the Repeal of Don’t Ask Don’t Tell a Victory?

Several of my friends have posted an article on Facebook arguing that the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell (DADT), the military’s policy that bans gay men and lesbians from serving openly in the military, is not a victory for economic justice. I agree.

But. I think the article misses some important points. My take:

The authors are right to say that military service should not be the only jobs program available and that government funds could be better used, and the poor better served, by other types of economic development. The problem is this: whether or not the military SHOULD be the de facto jobs program, it HAS been the de facto jobs program. This means that gay men and lesbians (who, contrary to popular notions, are not always better off economically) have joined the military as a way to better their economic situation. The repeal of DADT is a victory for them.

The repeal of DADT is a victory for other reasons, too. It is a victory for gay and straight service members who have been targeted and forced out using the ban’s vague language and murky enforcement policies. While I am fairly certain that a good number of gay service people will remain in the closet, despite the repeal, at least it will not be a weapon in the arsenal of people who would go to any lengths to ruin the careers of others.

Regardless of what people think about the military, military funding, war, peace, justice, etc., the repeal of DADT is a victory for GLBT folks in general. I’m not saying “wooo whoo, now gay people are included in the military and that means they will be accepted into society” (as though societal acceptance or “normalcy” is even a good thing, necessarily), but it is one more nail in the coffin of the extreme right and those that would use religion, hate, fear and misinformation to steer the entire country away from policies that include GLBT folks. And that’s a good thing. [Read more...]

Women suffer more under Don’t Ask Don’t Tell

A few weeks ago I posted about the ongoing problem with sexual assault against female service members. The issue represents but one of the hurdles facing women who take it upon themselves to serve and sacrifice for our country. The controversial Don’t Ask Don’t Tell policy, for instance, has a much larger negative impact on female service members than male, and serves to maintain sexism found in every level of the armed forces.

Although women made up only 15% of the armed forces in 2008, 34% of service members discharged under Don’t Ask Don’t Tell (DADT) were women. This dynamic varies greatly between the various branches of service. For instance, women make up only 20% of members in the air force, yet made up 62% of Air Force discharges under DADT (2008).

While DADT has a larger impact on gay women than gay men, the policy actually has a negative impact on all servicewomen, regardless of sexual orientation. “Lesbian baiting,” “the practice of pressuring women for sex and sexually harassing women by using the threat of calling then lesbians as a means of intimidation,” is common in all levels of the military. [Read more...]

The House Votes to Begin the Repeal of ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’

About damn time if you ask me.

The House voted Thursday to let the Defense Department repeal the ban on gay and bisexual people from serving openly in the military, a major step toward dismantling the 1993 law widely known as “don’t ask, don’t tell.”

The provision would allow military commanders to repeal the ban. The repeal would permit gay men and lesbians to serve openly in the military for the first time.

[Read more...]

Wednesday Click List

Laura Bush: Pro-Gay Marriage? – Gay Politics
Don’t Ask Don’t Tell Could Still Be Repealed This Year – Gay Politics
Would You Sell Your Ova to Make Some Cash? – Tenured Radical
Is Elena Kagan a Lesbian? – Mother Jones
Liberals, Conservatives, and Abortion – New York Times
The AIDS Epidemic Enters Old Age – Poz Magazine

Obama Administration Confirms Ludicrous Timeline for Repealing ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’

It probably isn’t news to anyone here that President Obama is still buying himself time on the issue of ‘Don’t Ask Don’t Tell’. Despite recent efforts by the President to increase equality for the LGBT community, Obama has still managed to sideline his commitment to repealing DADT in favor of political capital. This couldn’t have been made any more apparent than in the recent announcement by Press Secretary Gibbs.

Gibbs confirmed that the President is committed to a time line that gives the Pentagon until December 1 to study the issue.

A reporter pointed out that made passage of a repeal of Don’t Ask Don’t Tell impossible this year. Gibbs told reporters, “Well, again — the House and the Senate are obviously a different branch of government. The President has a process and a proposal, I think, that he believes is the best way forward to seeing, again, the commitment that he’s made for many years in trying to — changing that law.”

[Read more...]

Tuesday News Roundup

First Woman President of Chile Score Points on Gender Front – IPS News
Malaysia Canes Women for Adultery – AWID
Honoring Dr. Mildred Hanson – Physicians for Reproductive Choice & Health
Did the US Military Spy on Planned Parenthood? – AlterNet
Rachel Maddow on Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell – Pam’s House Blend

Repealing ‘Don’t Ask Don’t Tell’ as a National Priority

Don't Ask Don't Tell silences voicesYes, I said it. A national priority. For far too long we have had to sit back, waiting around for the president to get the courage to act righteously, while his administration works to acquiesce the LGBT community with tokenist attempts to include a “gay” agenda. Since 1993, when Clinton’s good intention manifested itself into a destructive policy known as ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,’ roughly 13,500 U.S. citizens serving in the armed forces have been discharged. Professional, courageous, committed, intelligent, service members with merit and passion are being turned away because of who they choose to love and who they choose to sleep with. Nearly $363 million dollars have been waisted within the span of 16 years, to enforce a policy that tells people they are less then human if they are gay, lesbian, trans, or bisexual.

According to a 2008 Washington Post-ABC news poll, 75 percent of Americans believe openly gay people should be allowed to serve. Right now there are roughly 65,000 homosexuals serving in the U.S. military, along with one million gay veterans. This is not a debate about a couple LGBT identified soldiers wanting access to the armed forces, and even if it were, it doesn’t change the truth about how net-detrimental DADT is to every person in our country. [Read more...]

DADT – A Story of Discrimination in the US Air-force Academy

DADT discriminatesKevin Calderwood, a passionate friend and ally to the community, came to me with a story of a friend intimately affected by the ‘Don’t Ask Don’t Tell’ policy. Rather then attempt to represent his words, I would rather you read them for yourself. Kevin Calderwood is a full time student at Southern Illinois University, double majoring in political science and history. When he isn’t busy winning national championships in parliamentary debate, he’s committed to organizing and repealing the DADT. Here are his words.

I am writing this in a state of mind where I am upset and angry, so I apologize in advance if I am not making a lot of sense. For the last several years I have felt the need for the United States armed forces to allow gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and trans identified people to openly serve in the military. Until now, however, I have not been active on the issue beyond voting for politicians that have promised to repeal DADT. Most people in life are not active on political issues until they truly effect you or people you know. I have a friend that is a fully commissioned officer in the United States Air Force that is under threat of a dishonorable discharge and huge financial loss, not to mention all the horrors he has experienced because of the life he was forced to lead secretly. [Read more...]

Monday News Roundup

footballThis weekend marked the official kick off of the NFL season. Hope you got your fill of football. And if you’re looking for a feminist fantasy football league to join, we’ve still got room for a few more players in our league. E-mail me for the details today so that we can set our draft.

Here’s your morning round up:

Minorities Disproportionately Affected by DADT – Gaypolitics.com
Scott Roeder Does Not Meet the Definitions of “Justifiable Homicide” – Roeder Watch
Center for Reproductive Rights Debuts Youtube Video About Clinic Violence – Words of Choice
Responding to the Arguments Against ENDA – Bilerico

Don’t Ask Don’t Tell: Scripting Hegemonic Masculinity

It has been sixteen years since the conception of the Don’t Ask Don’t tell policy, initially implemented by Clinton in 1993. Now, more then ever, this policy is under extreme scrutiny as people are contesting the policy as outdated, discriminatory and in dire need of change.

As a quick background for those who may not be familiar with the policy, it basically states that the military will not investigate homosexual behavior of individual servicemen and servicewomen unless there is credible suspicion. Gay and lesbian members of the military are reduced to a life of secrecy as they are faced with two options: stay in the closet, or be discharged from the military.

There have been numerous discharges from the military due to the DADT policy, including scores of translators of various Middle Eastern languages who were proficient at their jobs and in high demand considering our current military operations throughout the Middle East. The justifications for such a policy from the words of the pentagon, “The presence in the armed forces of persons who demonstrate a propensity or intent to engage in homosexual acts would create an unacceptable risk to high standards of morale, good order and discipline, and unit cohesion that are the essence of military capability.”
[Read more...]